5605 Comments So Farhttp%3A%2F%2Fwestchesterdish.com%2Frestaurant%2Fbennys-pizzeria%2FBenny%26%23039%3Bs+Pizzeria2007-05-10+02%3A50%3A48Mary+Bighamhttp%3A%2F%2Fwestchesterdish.com%2Fbennys-pizza%2F
I have been going to Benny's for over 30 years, and while the pizza is good, the best item is the regular stromboli. It is made with ham & cheese, but don't ask for a ham & cheese stromboli, make sure you ask for a Regular. Gooey, spicy, melted cheese and ham is better than any around. Good cheesesteaks too.
Benny's has great cheesesteaks. On the raves of many people, I finally tried Lorenzo's and it wasn't nearly as good as Benny's. The key is a great Italian roll. Also, they have great pizza here, with some unusual choices you wouldn't expect at a small place like this. Try the BBQ or the Bacon Ranch – Yummmm! Also, the best bargain on the menu is the small grilled Caesar salad. It's not that small, and it's only $3.15!!! A full chicken breast on top of fresh romaine. One thing that's unusual is that it comes with tomatoes as well.
Also been going to Benny's for at least 20 years, and they still have some of the best steaks around. Not the most meat, but just a perfect combination of roll, meat, and cheese. What else do you need? I don't live in WC any more, but when we pass through, we always make a stop here.
I have had Benny's a decent amount of times and it is definitely below average(I can walk there, thats why i went)
Pizza is average at best. Ive had it really underdone where I had to throw it in the oven myself. It just really isn't that good of a pie…anyone who says this is good pizza eats at Pizza Hut. Lets be serious people.
5 Comments So Far
I have been going to Benny's for over 30 years, and while the pizza is good, the best item is the regular stromboli. It is made with ham & cheese, but don't ask for a ham & cheese stromboli, make sure you ask for a Regular. Gooey, spicy, melted cheese and ham is better than any around. Good cheesesteaks too.
Benny's has great cheesesteaks. On the raves of many people, I finally tried Lorenzo's and it wasn't nearly as good as Benny's. The key is a great Italian roll. Also, they have great pizza here, with some unusual choices you wouldn't expect at a small place like this. Try the BBQ or the Bacon Ranch – Yummmm! Also, the best bargain on the menu is the small grilled Caesar salad. It's not that small, and it's only $3.15!!! A full chicken breast on top of fresh romaine. One thing that's unusual is that it comes with tomatoes as well.
Also been going to Benny's for at least 20 years, and they still have some of the best steaks around. Not the most meat, but just a perfect combination of roll, meat, and cheese. What else do you need? I don't live in WC any more, but when we pass through, we always make a stop here.
I have had Benny's a decent amount of times and it is definitely below average(I can walk there, thats why i went)
Pizza is average at best. Ive had it really underdone where I had to throw it in the oven myself. It just really isn't that good of a pie…anyone who says this is good pizza eats at Pizza Hut. Lets be serious people.
Hoagies are average..a bit overpriced.
Calzones are terrible
Haven't tried the steaks yet but I will update
While I can not comment on their Pizza, steaks or sandwiches, Benny's makes the best strombolis I have ever had. Try the regular Italian.